How do you check investments in an audit?
|
Detailed below are some individual tests that can be applied in order to help satisfy the objectives noted in Audit objectives. It may not be appropriate to undertake all of the tests; in each case, the auditor should review this bank of tests and determine which are most appropriate for the circumstances of the particular client being dealt with.
The auditor should, however, ensure that each objective is satisfied. Where the balance includes accounting estimates, refer to the guidance in Auditing accounting estimates. To subscribe to this content, simply call 0800 231 5199 We can create a package that’s catered to your individual needs. Or
book a demo to see this product in action. Whether you are preparing for your first investment company audit, or just need a refresher as to what your auditor should be looking for, the following information will be helpful in setting your expectations. Your auditors should send the engagement letter, pre-audit communication to those in charge of governance, and information request lists in advance of fieldwork. Fieldwork may be done remotely if both the auditor and fund personnel are willing and able to correspond well remotely. The auditors may divide the audit into two pieces: preliminary fieldwork and final fieldwork. Preliminary fieldwork would be conducted before the fund’s year end and include the planning phases of the audit. Preliminary procedures may include: understanding the entity, assessing the risks of the fund, documenting the internal control processes, walking through key controls to ensure they are operating effectively, performing preliminary analytical procedures, preparing audit confirmations (such and cash, investment, and legal confirmations), and getting a head start on some of the substantive testing. If preliminary fieldwork is not performed separately, it would be combined with final fieldwork. It is important to provide the auditors with the fund documents, including creation documents, partnership agreements, operating agreements, private placement memorandums, service agreements, lease agreements, any other important documents, and amendments to such documents. During the testing of the year end financials, your auditors will determine the nature and scope of testing based on their risk assessments. As such, the capital account activity, investments balances, and investment activity will likely be the main focus. Capital contributions, capital distributions and redemptions, management fees, carried interest, and performance allocations are generally tested. Be prepared to provide supporting subscription and redemption requests, bank statements, and other calculation worksheets. In testing investments, the auditor will test and evaluate management’s processes for determining fair values. The auditor will evaluate the reasonableness and consistency of assumptions, models, and calculations used, as well as the completeness, accuracy, and relevance of underlying data used. The auditor may develop an independent estimate using the same or alternative assumptions and inputs. But it is important to remember that assigning fair value to investments is the responsibility of management, not the auditors. Subsequent events and transactions that occur after year end but before the auditor’s report date will be considered and discussed. There will likely be inquiries, discussion, and requests related to the following auditor requirements:
The financial statements may be prepared by you or your administrator and provided to the auditor for the audit. Alternatively, if there is no SEC or PCAOB restriction, the preparation of the financial statements by the auditor may be permitted as long as management takes full responsibility for the financial statements and provides oversight. If you have any questions on the audit process or would like to discuss SC&H Group’s Audit practice and approach, please don’t hesitate to Contact Us. Knowing how to work with the numbers in a company's financial statements is an essential skill for stock investors. The meaningful interpretation and analysis of balance sheets, income statements, and cash flow statements to discern a company's investment qualities is the basis for smart investment choices. However, the diversity of financial reporting requires that we first become familiar with certain financial statement characteristics before focusing on individual corporate financials. In this article, we'll show you what the financial statements have to offer and how to use them to your advantage. Financial StatementsKey Takeaways
1. Financial Statement = ScorecardThere are millions of individual investors worldwide, and while a large percentage of these investors have chosen mutual funds as the vehicle of choice for their investing activities, many others are also investing directly in stocks. Prudent investing practices dictate that we seek out quality companies with strong balance sheets, solid earnings, and positive cash flows. Whether you're a do-it-yourself investor or rely on guidance from an investment professional, learning certain fundamental financial statement analysis skills can be very useful. Almost 30 years ago, businessman Robert Follett wrote a book entitled How To Keep Score In Business. His principal point was that in business you keep score with dollars, and the scorecard is a financial statement. He recognized that "a lot of people don't understand keeping score in business. They get mixed up about profits, assets, cash flow, and return on investment." The same thing could be said today about a large portion of the investing public, especially when it comes to identifying investment values in financial statements. But don't let this intimidate you; it can be done. 2. Financial Statements to UseThe financial statements used in investment analysis are the balance sheet, the income statement, and the cash flow statement with additional analysis of a company's shareholders' equity and retained earnings. Although the income statement and the balance sheet typically receive the majority of the attention from investors and analysts, it's important to include in your analysis the often overlooked cash flow statement. 3. What's Behind the Numbers?The numbers in a company's financial statements reflect the company's business, products, services, and macro-fundamental events. These numbers and the financial ratios or indicators derived from them are easier to understand if you can visualize the underlying realities of the fundamentals driving the quantitative information. For example, before you start crunching numbers, it's critical to develop an understanding of what the company does, its products and/or services, and the industry in which it operates. 4. Diversity of ReportingDon't expect financial statements to fit into a single mold. Many articles and books on financial statement analysis take a one-size-fits-all approach. Less-experienced investors might get lost when they encounter a presentation of accounts that falls outside the mainstream of a so-called "typical" company. Please remember that the diverse nature of business activities results in a diverse set of financial statement presentations. This is particularly true of the balance sheet; the income statement and cash flow statement are less susceptible to this phenomenon. 5. Understanding Financial JargonThe lack of any appreciable standardization of financial reporting terminology complicates the understanding of many financial statement account entries. This circumstance can be confusing for the beginning investor. There's little hope that things will change on this issue in the foreseeable future, but a good financial dictionary can help considerably. Investopedia's Glossary of Terms provides you with thousands of definitions and detailed explanations to help you understand terms related to finance, investing, and economics. 6. Accounting: Art, Not ScienceThe presentation of a company's financial position, as portrayed in its financial statements, is influenced by management's estimates and judgments. In the best of circumstances, management is scrupulously honest and candid, while the outside auditors are demanding, strict, and uncompromising. Whatever the case, the imprecision that can be inherently found in the accounting process means that the prudent investor should take an inquiring and skeptical approach toward financial statement analysis. 7. Key Accounting ConventionsGenerally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) or International Financial Reporting Standards (IFRS) are used to prepare financial statements. Both methods are legal in the United States, although GAAP is most commonly used. The main difference between the two methods is that GAAP is more "rules-based," while IFRS is more "principles-based." Both have different ways of reporting asset values, depreciation, and inventory, to name a few. 8. Non-Financial InformationInformation on the state of the economy, the industry, competitive considerations, market forces, technological change, the quality of management and the workforce are not directly reflected in a company's financial statements. Investors need to recognize that financial statement insights are but one piece, albeit an important one, of the larger investment puzzle. 9. Financial Ratios and IndicatorsThe absolute numbers in financial statements are of little value for investment analysis unless these numbers are transformed into meaningful relationships to judge a company's financial performance and gauge its financial health. The resulting ratios and indicators must be viewed over extended periods to spot trends. Please beware that evaluative financial metrics can differ significantly by industry, company size, and stage of development. 10. Notes to Financial StatementsThe financial statement numbers don't provide all of the disclosure required by regulatory authorities. Analysts and investors alike universally agree that a thorough understanding of the notes to financial statements is essential to properly evaluate a company's financial condition and performance. As noted by auditors on financial statements "the accompanying notes are an integral part of these financial statements." Please include a thorough review of the noted comments in your investment analysis. 11. The Annual Report/10-KPrudent investors should only consider investing in companies with audited financial statements, which are a requirement for all publicly-traded companies. Perhaps even before digging into a company's financials, an investor should look at the company's annual report and the 10-K. Much of the annual report is based on the 10-K, but contains less information and is presented in a marketable document intended for an audience of shareholders. The 10-K is reported directly to the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission or SEC and tends to contain more details than other reports. Included in the annual report is the auditor's report, which gives an auditor's opinion on how the accounting principles have been applied. A "clean opinion" provides you with a green light to proceed. Qualifying remarks may be benign or serious; in the case of the latter, you may not want to proceed. 12. Consolidated StatementsTypically, the word "consolidated" appears in the title of a financial statement, as in a consolidated balance sheet. A consolidation of a parent company and its majority-owned (more than 50% ownership or "effective control") subsidiaries means that the combined activities of separate legal entities are expressed as one economic unit. The presumption is that consolidation as one entity is more meaningful than separate statements for different entities. What is investment testing?Testing investments during an audit is no different from testing any other financial account, such as cash. You must make sure that the amounts shown as investment assets aren't materially misstated and that all income and changes in an investment's value are properly recorded.
What auditing procedure should be performed for investment accounted at fair value?The auditor should test the data used to develop the fair value measurements and disclosures and evaluate whether the fair value measurements have been properly determined from such data and management's assumptions.
|
