Is personal excess liability the same as an umbrella policy?

Editorial Note: We earn a commission from partner links on Forbes Advisor. Commissions do not affect our editors' opinions or evaluations.

Liability insurance protects you and your family’s finances when you cause major disasters, such as a lawsuit against you over a large car accident. For example, if you crash into someone else, liability car insurance pays for their medical bills, their property damage, and your legal defense costs—but only up to your liability insurance policy limits.

But what if these costs exceed the liability coverage in your auto or homeowners insurance policy? That’s where you need umbrella insurance.

What Is Umbrella Insurance?

Umbrella insurance provides “excess liability insurance” (simply meaning additional coverage) beyond the liability insurance already in your auto, homeowners and/or watercraft insurance policies. It’s for expensive situations where medical bills and/or repairs exceed your “base” auto, home or boat policies. You can think of it as asset protection because it can prevent you from losing your assets in order to pay for a lawsuit against you.

How Does Umbrella Insurance Work?

Umbrella insurance kicks in when your “base” liability limits have been reached. Here’s an example:

You cause a car accident that results in severe injuries for multiple people. Their medical bills total $400,000, which exceeds your $300,000 liability car insurance policy limits. Your umbrella insurance can cover the remaining $100,000.

To add to this example, let’s say one of the injured parties is a highly paid professional who cannot perform their job for six months because of the injuries and sues you to cover this time away from work. If your car insurance liability limits are exhausted, your assets—such as your house and savings—could be at risk without umbrella insurance.

Incidents where umbrella insurance could cover you

Here are examples of incidents where umbrella insurance could cover you:

You cause a serious auto or boating accident. Auto or boating accident bills can mount up quickly, especially if you’re responsible for the medical bills of multiple people. Your auto or boat insurance policy would pay first, up to its maximum, followed by your umbrella insurance.

Your dog bites someone. Dog bites are typically covered by a homeowners insurance policy. But if you’re sued for an amount above your home insurance liability limits (such as medical bills and pain and suffering), your umbrella policy would start paying.

You drive your car into a building. It happens—someone is parked close to a convenience store and they put the car in drive rather than reverse, causing extensive building damage. Your auto insurance policy would pay first, followed by an umbrella policy if your auto insurance limit isn’t enough.

You accidentally injure someone. If you or a family member accidentally injures someone, umbrella insurance will pay when auto or home insurance is exhausted. For example, say your son accidentally throws a baseball into someone’s face, causing extensive injury. Your homeowners liability insurance will pay first, followed by umbrella insurance.

You’re on a board of directors of a charity and are sued for a board-related issue. An umbrella policy may provide coverage for lawsuits against you related to your work on a board of directors. The coverage may depend on whether the board is a non-profit and whether you’re paid for your service. It’s best to consult your insurance agent to understand whether you’ll be covered.

Your teen is sued. Let’s say your teen posts a libelous comment online and is sued. Your umbrella insurance can pay for legal costs and judgments.

Your child accidentally causes damage to someone else’s property. If your child accidentally damages someone else’s property, your home insurance can pay out first, followed by umbrella insurance if the damage exceeds your home insurance liability limits.

What Does Umbrella Insurance Cover?

Umbrella insurance covers a wide range of problems and provides funds above and beyond the limits of your other policies, such as your car insurance or homeowners insurance. For example, if you cause a car accident and the medical bills for the other driver exceeds your car insurance policy limit, your umbrella insurance policy can kick in.

Umbrella insurance can also cover you for incidents homeowners insurance cannot, such as a defamation or slander lawsuit.

Members of your household—such as your spouse and children—are also generally covered by your umbrella insurance policy.

Umbrella insurance provides liability coverage for problems such as:

  • Bodily injury to others
  • Property damage to others
  • The legal costs to defend you in lawsuits related to these problems
  • Lawsuits such as defamation, libel, slander and invasion of privacy
  • Incidents that happen outside the U.S.

Umbrella coverage beyond the base insurance policy

Another advantage of umbrella insurance is that it usually provides coverage that’s not found in a base auto or homeowners policy at all. For example:

  • False arrest, imprisonment or detention
  • Malicious prosecution
  • Wrongful eviction or entry
  • Invasion of privacy

What Umbrella Insurance Won’t Cover

Umbrella insurance doesn’t cover your own injuries or damage to your own property. Here are other losses typically not covered by umbrella insurance:

  • Business losses
  • Criminal acts by you
  • Written or oral contracts
  • Intentional acts or injury by you
  • Damage due to nuclear radiation, war or terrorism
  • Communicable disease, such as a lawsuit against you for giving someone herpes

Do You Need Umbrella Insurance?

Wealthy households in particular need personal umbrella insurance. A wealthy individual or family can be a lawsuit target. In addition, these circumstances could increase your chances of being sued:

  • You serve on a charitable board
  • You have a swimming pool, pond or trampoline
  • You have dogs, horses or other large animals
  • You manage a family trust
  • You host large parties in your home
  • You employ household staff
  • You have a high public profile

How Much Umbrella Insurance Do I Need?

When selecting the right amount of coverage, there are things to consider.

  • Value of your assets: An umbrella policy should cover at least your net worth—this is generally what you stand to lose in a lawsuit.
  • Potential future income loss: Your future income could also be at risk in a big lawsuit. Even if you have a limited income now, consider your potential future income. For instance, if you’re a medical student, you should consider your future earning potential.

A long legal proceeding is stressful and can potentially ruin a reputation, whether or not the lawsuit was baseless. Purchasing an umbrella policy won’t ease the stress, but it can save everything you’ve worked so hard to build.

How Much Does Umbrella Insurance Cost?

Umbrella insurance costs an average of $383 a year for $1 million in coverage, according to an ACE Private Risk Services report, a company that sells high net worth personal insurance and operates under the Chubb name.

When you’re getting an umbrella insurance quote, an insurer will base the rate on factors such as:

  • Where you live
  • Your credit history
  • Your driving record
  • Your risk of filing an umbrella insurance claim

Average umbrella insurance cost for a person with one home, two cars and two drivers

Average umbrella insurance cost for a person with three homes, four cars, one boat and three drivers, including one driver under age 25

How to Buy Umbrella Insurance

Umbrella insurance is commonly available from insurers that sell auto, home and boat insurance. You’ll generally need to buy umbrella insurance from the company that provides your auto and/or homeowners insurance. Umbrella insurance is also available to people who buy renters insurance.

You’ll need to buy a certain amount of liability insurance in the base policy before you can add umbrella insurance. For example, you might need to have:

  • Home insurance: $300,000 in liability
  • Auto insurance: $100,000 per person/$300,000 per occurrence for bodily injury and $100,000 for property damage, or more
  • Watercraft insurance: $300,000 in liability

What Should I Consider When Choosing a Personal Umbrella Policy?

When you are choosing a personal umbrella insurance policy, you want to make sure you buy an adequate coverage amount. Here are some tips to consider:

  • Estimate the total value of your assets. Your umbrella coverage amount should align with your net worth.
  • Review your insurance policies. Look at the liability insurance amounts on your existing policies, such as your car insurance and home insurance. If the liability insurance is insufficient for covering your net worth, look into umbrella insurance.

Since your financial situation can change over the years, it’s a good idea to review your insurance policies regularly. For example, if your net worth grows, you want to increase the liability limits on your insurance policies (including your umbrella policy).

Best Car Insurance Companies 2022

With so many choices for car insurance companies, it can be hard to know where to start to find the right car insurance. We've evaluated insurers to find the best car insurance companies, so you don't have to.

Umbrella Insurance FAQ

What are the best umbrella insurance companies?

A good place to start when looking for umbrella insurance is checking with your current auto insurance or homeowners insurance company. Ask your insurance company if you can bundle your home or auto policy with an umbrella policy, which may result in a discount.

Some of the top homeowners insurance companies include Erie Insurance, USAA and Auto-Owners, which all offer umbrella insurance coverage. Top car insurance companies include Geico, Nationwide and Travelers, and they all offer umbrella insurance policies as well.

Check out Chubb if you need substantially high umbrella limits. Chubb offers umbrella insurance limits up to $100 million (others insurers’ highest limits tend to top out at $5 million or $10 million).

Is umbrella insurance worth it?

If you have significant assets, it’s worth getting an umbrella policy. The liability insurance within your auto and homeowners insurance policies might not be sufficient if you get sued for an incident such as dog bite, car accident or accidental injury to someone else.

Ultimately, umbrella insurance protects you from losing everything in a lawsuit.

But umbrella policies aren’t only for people who have amassed wealth. Some volunteer activities could leave you exposed to lawsuits, such as those who serve on a board of directors for charities.

How much is a $1 million umbrella policy?

A person with one home, two cars and two drivers will pay an average of $383 a year for $1 million in umbrella insurance, according to an ACE Private Risk Services report. A person with three homes, one boat, four cars and three drivers (including a driver under 25 years old) would pay an average of $563 annually for $1 million in umbrella coverage.

Is umbrella insurance the same as excess liability insurance?

Yes, the term umbrella insurance is often used to mean excess liability insurance.

If you have assets that total more than your home insurance and car insurance policy limits, you may benefit from extra coverage in case you cause damage or injuries to someone else that exceeds your base policy’s coverage limits.

What is the most that an umbrella insurance will pay?

The most your umbrella insurance will pay is up to your policy limit.

For example, if you have a $1 million umbrella insurance policy and you are found liable in a lawsuit, your umbrella insurance will only pay up to that amount. You can generally buy umbrella insurance in increments of $1 million, such as a $10 million umbrella insurance policy.

Is personal liability the same as umbrella?

Umbrella insurance is a type of personal liability insurance that covers claims in excess of regular homeowners, auto, or watercraft policy coverage. Umbrella insurance covers not just the policyholder, but also other members of their family or household.

What is another name for umbrella liability?

Umbrella insurance is often referred to as excess liability insurance. If a policyholder is sued for damages that exceed the liability limits of car insurance, homeowners insurance, or other coverage types, an umbrella policy helps pay what they owe.

What is an umbrella personal liability policy?

An umbrella personal liability policy is extra liability coverage which goes beyond the limits of the insured's home, auto or other liability coverage. It provides an additional layer of security to those who are at risk of high loss if they injure someone else, or someone's property.

What is a primary difference between umbrella and excess liability policies quizlet?

Excess coverage is no broader than the underlying insurance. Umbrella coverage is broader than underlying coverage. List two reasons why, in actual practice, the distinction between excess and umbrella liability coverage is often unclear.